Need to Know Tax Income Tax 2026 · Federal & Colorado

Need to Know Tax › Deductions, credits, and gains

Deductions, credits, and gains

Collectibles: coins, cards, art and the 28% rate

Why the $20,000 profit that costs a stock seller nothing can cost a collector $2,400, what the tax code counts as a collectible, and where sports cards and memorabilia sold on eBay fit.

Charles Trautman, EA

By Charles Trautman, EA

The Tax Shop  ·  Lone Tree, Colorado  ·  Reviewed November 18, 2026

Sell a coin, a painting, a case of old bourbon or a rookie card for more than you paid and the profit is a capital gain, but not the kind most people have read about. A long-term gain on a collectible does not get the 0%, 15% and 20% rates that stock gets. It is taxed at your ordinary bracket rate, up to a ceiling of 28%. Whether the item is a collectible in the tax code’s sense, whether you are a collector or a dealer, and what you can prove you paid decide the rest.

The 28% is a ceiling, not the rate

A collectible held more than a year is long-term, as with any asset. The gain goes on top of your other income and is taxed at whatever ordinary brackets it lands in, except that no part of it is taxed above 28%. A retired couple in the 12% bracket pays 12%. A working couple in the 22% bracket pays 22%. Only people in the 32%, 35% and 37% brackets are helped by the ceiling. The 0% rate that stock enjoys does not exist for a collectible.

Held one year or less, the gain is short-term and taxed like wages with no ceiling. Up through the 24% bracket that is the same rate you would have paid long-term, so for most collectors the one-year line changes nothing. Above it, waiting past a year caps the rate at 28%. The 3.8% net investment income tax applies on top, above $200,000 of modified AGI single or $250,000 joint.

Worked example: the same $20,000 gain, stock or collectible

The three sellers from Capital gains, each with a $20,000 long-term gain. The only thing that changes is what they sold.

Retired coupleWorking coupleHigh earner, single
Taxable income before the gain$60,000$150,000$600,000
Taxable income with the gain$80,000$170,000$620,000
Federal tax if they sold stock$0$3,000$4,760
Rate if they sold a collectible12%22%28% + 3.8%
Federal tax on the collectible$2,400$4,400$6,360
Colorado tax at 4.40%$880$880$880

For 2026 the 12% bracket on a joint return ends at $100,800 and the 22% bracket at $211,400, so each couple’s whole gain sits in one bracket. The single filer is in the 35% bracket and is capped at 28%. Colorado charges the same $880 on all three, collectible or stock.

What counts as a collectible

The definition sits in the retirement account rules, section 408(m) of the Code, and the capital gains rules borrow it. The list is short:

The Treasury has never named anything under that last line. A regulation proposed in 1984 would have added musical instruments and historical objects such as documents and clothing. It was never made final.

Gold and silver. Bullion and coins are collectibles when you sell them, including the American Eagles and investment-grade bars that an IRA is allowed to hold. Shares of a fund that owns the physical metal are taxed the same way, and the broker’s 1099-B has a box for it. Shares of a mining company are ordinary stock.

Sports cards, memorabilia, comics and toys. These are not on the list. Trading cards, comic books, dolls, sneakers, video games and most sports memorabilia are not named in the statute, and neither the IRS nor a court has ruled on them. Most preparers report them as collectibles anyway. That is the cautious answer and the one least likely to be questioned. The other reading, that an item not on the list gets the regular 0%, 15% and 20% rates, follows the words of the statute, and the New York State Bar Association’s tax section said as much to the IRS in a 2023 report. A particular piece can still land on the list as an antique, a work of art or a historical object: a game-worn jersey from 1960 is closer to the list than a card printed in 2020. Where the difference is real money, and in the example it is $2,400 for the retired couple, it is a decision to make with your preparer before the return is filed.

Digital collectibles. For an NFT the IRS looks through to what the token stands for. A token for a gem is a collectible; a token for a plot in a video game is not. See The digital asset question.

Collector, investor or dealer

The same sale is taxed three different ways depending on why you owned the item.

You areBecause youA gain isA loss is
Collectorbought it to enjoyCapital gain on Form 8949 and Schedule DPersonal, and not deductible
Investorbought and held it mainly to sell at a profitCapital gain on Form 8949 and Schedule DA capital loss: it offsets other gains, then $3,000 a year of other income
Dealerbuy in order to resell, regularlyBusiness income on Schedule C at ordinary rates, plus 15.3% self-employment tax, with no 28% ceilingA business loss, with inventory and expenses deducted

Selling off your own collection does not make you a dealer, even over a couple of hundred eBay listings. Buying to resell does: breaking cases, flipping at shows, a steady stream of purchases meant for sale. The tests are in Is it a business or a hobby?

Sales tax is a separate matter from income tax. eBay and the other large marketplaces collect it from the buyer in every state that has one. Someone who sells regularly at shows or from their own website may need a state permit.

Behind the scenes

Nothing on a 1099-K says “collectible,” and eBay does not know what you paid. On Form 8949 the preparer lists each sale and marks a collectible with code C. That one letter sends the gain to the 28% Rate Gain Worksheet and Schedule D line 18 instead of the regular worksheet. Leave it off a coin sale and the software taxes gold like a share of stock. Put it on a card sale and the retired couple’s $0 becomes $2,400. So a preparer has to ask three things the paperwork does not show: what the item was, when you got it, and why you bought it.

Basis: what you can prove you paid

The tax is on the profit, not on the sale price. Your basis comes off first, and so do the costs of selling.

If you bought it. Basis is the price plus any buyer’s premium, sales tax and shipping, plus later grading, authentication, restoration or framing. Platform fees, the auction house’s commission, shipping and insurance on the sale reduce what you received.

If you pulled it from a pack. Basis is that card’s share of what the pack or box cost, usually a few dollars. Nearly the whole sale price is gain.

If you inherited it. Basis is the value on the date of death, and the gain is long-term however soon you sell. A collection sold within months of a death usually has little gain, which is why an appraisal as of that date is worth paying for. See Inherited property and the step-up in basis.

If it was a gift. You take over the giver’s basis and holding period. Coins your father bought in 1975 and gave you last year carry his 1975 cost.

If you have no records. Without proof the IRS can treat the basis as zero and tax the full price. Rebuild what you can: old receipts and auction invoices, bank and card statements, a price guide from the year you bought. A reasonable figure with something behind it is far better than none.

A 1099-K reports gross sales, not profit. For 2026 a marketplace has to send one only when your sales pass $20,000 and 200 transactions, but the gain is taxable whether a form arrives or not. See Venmo, PayPal, Etsy, eBay: the 1099-K.

Losses

A collector’s loss is personal. It is not deductible, and it does not offset the gain on another piece: sell one card at a $15,000 gain and the rest of the box at a $3,000 loss, and the tax is on $15,000. An investor’s losses do net against gains. For either one, losses on stock and funds, including a loss carried forward from earlier years, offset a collectibles gain, and the worksheet uses them against the 28% gain first.

Ways to lower the tax

Split the sale across two years. Half in December and half in January can keep each half in a lower bracket. It also limits what the gain does to the taxable share of Social Security and to the Medicare premium two years out, which is often the larger cost for a retiree.

Sell losers the same year. A stock or fund sitting at a loss, sold in the year of the collectible sale, comes off the 28% gain dollar for dollar.

Take payment over time. A private sale paid in installments is taxed as the payments arrive, which spreads the gain over those years.

Give it instead of selling it. Given to a museum, school or historical society that will use it in its work, a collectible you have owned more than a year is deductible at its appraised value, and nobody pays tax on the gain. Given to a charity that will simply sell it, the deduction drops to what you paid. Anything over $5,000 needs a qualified appraisal and Form 8283. See Charitable giving.

Keep it. A collection left to heirs gets a new basis at death and the gain built up over your lifetime is never taxed. One given away during life passes your basis along with it. See Gift and estate taxes.

Three things do not work. Trading one piece for another is a sale of the piece you gave up; like-kind exchanges have been limited to real estate since 2018. An IRA cannot hold collectibles: one that buys a painting or a rare coin is treated as having paid the purchase price out to you, with a narrow exception for certain U.S. coins and bullion held by the trustee. And nothing is withheld from an eBay payout or an auction check, so a large sale usually calls for an estimated payment for that quarter. The last one for 2026 is due January 15, 2027. See Estimated payments.

The Colorado side

Colorado has no collectibles rate and no long-term rate. It starts from federal taxable income and applies its flat 4.40%, so the $20,000 gain costs $880 whether it came from a coin or a share of stock, and whether the federal rate on it was 12% or 28%. A stepped-up basis on inherited pieces and any loss allowed federally carry straight through, and there is no Colorado form on which collectibles are listed separately.

What to bring your preparer

  • What you sold, the date and the price, with the platform’s annual sales and fee summary or the auction house’s settlement statement
  • Any Form 1099-K or 1099-B
  • How and when you got each item: bought, inherited, received as a gift, or pulled from a pack
  • Proof of cost: receipts, invoices, card or bank statements, and bills for grading, authentication or restoration
  • For anything inherited: the date of death and an appraisal or price guide value as of that date
  • Whether you bought it to enjoy, to invest, or to resell, and how often you buy and sell
  • Last year’s complete return, for any capital loss carried forward
  • If the sale has not happened yet: the expected price and your other income for the year, so the sale can be timed

Questions people ask

I sold $23,000 of sports cards on eBay this year in fewer than 200 sales. Do I need a business license?

Not for income tax, if the cards came out of your own collection. You are a collector with a capital gain, reported on Form 8949 and Schedule D, with no self-employment tax. Under 200 sales, eBay may not send a 1099-K, but the gain is taxable either way. It becomes a business only if you are buying in order to resell. A state sales tax permit is a separate question that depends on your state and on whether you are in the business of selling.

Are my cards taxed at 28%?

At your own bracket rate, up to 28%, if they are reported as collectibles, and only on the profit. In the 12% bracket that is 12%. Whether cards are collectibles under the statute at all is unsettled, as explained above, and it matters most to people in the lower brackets, where stock would have been taxed at 0%.

I inherited my father’s coin collection and sold it. What do I owe?

Often very little. Your basis is the collection’s value on the day he died, not what he paid, so only the change in value since then is gain. Get that value in writing.

I traded one card for another and no money changed hands. Is that taxable?

Yes. You are treated as selling the card you gave up for the value of the card you received. That value becomes your basis in the new one.

I own a gold fund in my brokerage account. Is that a stock or a collectible?

If the fund holds the physical metal, a long-term gain is a collectibles gain with the 28% ceiling, and the 1099-B should have the collectibles box checked. A fund that holds mining shares is taxed like any stock fund.

I sold my collection for less than I paid. Can I deduct the loss?

Not if you collected for enjoyment. If you bought and held the pieces as an investment, the loss is a capital loss, and you should be ready to show it: how they were stored, whether they were displayed, and what records you kept.

Know what it is before you sell it

Three questions decide the tax on a collectible: is it on the list, why did you buy it, and what can you prove you paid. All three are easier to answer before the sale than the following April.

Written by Charles Trautman, EA, editor  ·  Need to Know Tax, Lone Tree, Colorado

Questions about this article in Colorado are answered by [your practice name]  ·  [your phone]  ·  [your email address]. We’re looking for an EA or CPA in each Colorado city to hold that city’s seat and take this spot — is that you?

Ask a question about this article →

Forms and official pages named in this article

Sources and where to check

Updated November 18, 2026 · tax year 2026 figures